Finding Your Theme

If you happen to enjoy this article, why not stay in touch by signing up to my mailing list? Subscribers receive a list of 50 fantasy book reviewers, as well as a copy of This Craft We Call Writing: Volume One, a collection of writing techniques, advice, and guides looking at, amongst others, world-building, writing fight scenes, characterisation, plotting, editing and prose.

 


 

Today I’m looking at an aspect of the craft which can elevate stories from mere sequences of events to something which moves readers on an emotional level: theme.

Theme takes a hard look at the meaning of things, examines deep-rooted ideas.[i] A story with a theme is a story with a point.[ii]

It’s only when the writer considers the theme of a story “does he achieve not just an alternative reality, or loosely, an imitation of nature, but true, firm art—fiction as serious thought.”[iii]

This article looks at the definition of ‘theme’ before exploring ways for you to come up with or uncover your themes and lastly, how to weave them into your stories.

 

1. What’s a theme and why is it important?

As eluded to above, the theme of a story is what it’s about, what it means.[iv] It should not be confused with plot—the two are separate elements, yet linked. For example, if we look at the classic story of Romeo and Juliet, the plot is about two individuals from rival families falling in love and dying as a result of a series of tragic events. But that’s not what the story is about. The themes, in simple terms, look at love, fate, and family, amongst others.

romeo_and_juliet_from_'children's_stories_from_shakespeare'_by_edith_nesbit_(1858_1924)_pub_by_raphael_tuck_sons_ltd_london.jpg

The theme provides the platform for the writer to leave their mark, to put forward their views on a particular topic or idea. It’s the job of the writer to “dig out the fundamental meaning of events by organising the imitation of reality [the story] around some primary question or theme suggested by the character’s concern.”[v]

As we’ll see below, a theme doesn’t have to be based on morality. It can be a more general idea, a topic which reappears throughout a story.[vi]

 

2. Coming up with a theme

American novelist John Gardner (who had the interesting middle name ‘Champlin’) argued that theme is not imposed on a story, but rather evoked from within it. Initially it’s intuitive, but finally becomes an intellectual consideration on the part of the writer.[vii] While other writers agree with this approach, it’s not the only one to take when considering the theme. It can be engineered into your story, considered beforehand to give it focus, to help you make out your argument.[viii]

But a theme should not consume your story. It’s just one component. Writer and blogger Chuck Wendig describes it as “a drop of poison: subtle, unseen.”[ix] Don’t make it too subtle though, otherwise, it may bypass your readers.

confused.gif

Stumped

Below you’ll find a few ways of coming up with themes, and we’ll start with some common examples.

2.1 Examples of common themes

When you seek out examples of themes you’ll invariably find lists of single-word suggestions. It’s important to remember that while it’s helpful to summarise themes in this way, they should not be limited to just that one word. Instead, think of it as an essay question you’d find in school or university. You’re asked to explore or criticise a concept, and in essence, you’re doing the same with your theme.

“Theme can be a broad topical arena, or it can be a specific stance on anything human beings experience in life.”[x]

It should be borne in mind that a theme is not a question, it’s the answer. The process of exploring the theme in your story is the journey your characters go on to come to realise this answer.  

Here are a few examples:

  • Alienation – the effects of it, how to fight it.
  • Betrayal – how the pain feels, attitude changes to friends and loved ones.
  • Coming of Age – the loss of childhood innocence, the shift from childhood to adulthood, or a significant step in personal growth.
  • Courage – courage to face adversity, to deal with conflict, the development of it, or the loss of it.
  • Discovery – discovering new places, revealing information, inner meaning, inner strength, treasures.
  • Death – how to escape it, facing it, dealing with the effects of it.
  • Fear – conquering it, coping with it, the crippling effects of it.
  • Freedom – losing it, longing for it, striving to achieve it, fighting for it.
  • Good Versus Evil – the struggle between the two opposing forces, the triumph of one over the other.
  • Justice – the fight for it, injustices, seeking the truth.
  • Loss – of life, innocence, possessions, freedoms.
  • Love conquers all – love provides the motivation to overcome an obstacle.
  • Religion – the effect religion has on individuals, how beliefs shape their lives, extremists such as cults, sin, the afterlife.
  • Power – gaining it, handling it, losing it, fighting for it.

 

ying-yang-classic-black-white-spinning-animated-gif.gif

 

2.2 Helpful questions to ask yourself

There are two simple questions you can put to yourself to help evoke the theme of your story. You can ask yourself these questions at any stage of the writing process—beginning, middle, or end, and it’s always helpful to keep them before you to maintain focus.

  1.  What is the meaning of things?
  2. What deep-rooted idea is being examined?

 

2.3 The secret snapshot approach

This technique is helpful for giving your story an emotional edge, an edge so sharp it cuts through to your theme and moves the reader. The theory is simple, the practice is a little trickier.

enqueteur-prive.jpg

Master editor Sol Stein utilised this approach when teaching his writing students. He first asked them to think of a snapshot of a memory so private that if that snapshot was a tangible image they wouldn’t carry it in their wallet or purse in case anyone found it, family included.[xi]

“Some writers squirm through the process, shifting uncomfortably in their seats. That’s a good sign.”[xii]

As an exercise, write down what you see in your most secret snapshot. Be brutally honest. To help, I’ll give my own example. I have a vivid recollection of the day my mum and dad told me they were splitting up. I was about thirteen. I remember crying about not being able to go to football training anymore, which my dad took me to each day after school. Looking back, what I was really upset about was the fact that my life was never going to be the same again, that the image of the life I knew was being shattered before my eyes.

When you’ve come up with your example, ask yourself whether you’d carry your snapshot in your purse or wallet. If yes, think of another. You want to reach deep into your emotional memories and find the most personal. “The best fiction reveals the hidden things we usually don’t want to talk about.”[xiii]

You can also look to conjure the secret snapshots of other people, ones that you wouldn’t be allowed to see under any circumstance. The bravest writing someone can do is to explore the recesses in which the secret snapshots of their friends, enemies, and themselves are stored.[xiv]

 

3. Revealing your theme

To finish, we’ll take a quick look at how to reveal your theme in a story. I referred to Chuck Wendig above and how he says that a theme should be subtle. How do you achieve this subtlety?

Let’s take the theme of nakedness as an example. You could consider adding details to suggest nakedness, for instance, the chipping paint of a wall, characters who show a lot of skin, or the psychological nakedness of a character.[xv]

18440921-paint-chipping-on-wall.jpg

There are instances where it’s fine to be direct with showing your theme. For example, how Forrest Gump tells us that ‘life is like a box of chocolates, you never know what you’re gonna’ get’, just like the film itself.[xvi]

Another method you can utilise to reveal theme is to feature ‘counters.’ These are things which contrast with your theme, so for example with nakedness, you could have a character who always wears two jumpers regardless of the weather.[xvii]

JoyousEminentAngwantibo-size_restricted.gif


Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed this article, why not stay in touch by signing up to my mailing list? Subscribers receive a list of 50 fantasy book reviewers, as well as a copy of This Craft We Call Writing: Volume One, a collection of writing techniques, advice, and guides looking at, amongst others, world-building, writing fight scenes, characterisation, plotting, editing and prose.

 


References

[i] Pg. 176, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

[ii] http://terribleminds.com/ramble/2011/09/26/25-things-writers-should-know-about-theme/

[iii] Pg. 178, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

[iv] https://thewritersacademy.co.uk/blog/common-literary-themes/

[v] Pg. 176, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

[vi] https://thewritersacademy.co.uk/blog/common-literary-themes/

[vii] Pg. 178, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

[viii] http://terribleminds.com/ramble/2011/09/26/25-things-writers-should-know-about-theme/

[ix] http://terribleminds.com/ramble/2011/09/26/25-things-writers-should-know-about-theme/

[x] http://www.writersdigest.com/tip-of-the-day/exploring-theme-a-key-component-to-successful-writing

[xi] Pg. 156, On Writing, S. Stein, 1995.

[xii] Pg. 157, On Writing, S. Stein, 1995.

[xiii] Pg. 157, On Writing, S. Stein, 1995.

[xiv] Pg. 158, On Writing, S. Stein, 1995.

[xv] Pg. 177, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

[xvi] http://terribleminds.com/ramble/2011/09/26/25-things-writers-should-know-about-theme/

[xvii] Pg. 177, ‘The Art of Fiction: Notes on Craft for Young Writers’, J. Gardner 1983

9 thoughts on “Finding Your Theme”

  1. Hi Richie, Fascinating stuff. Being an ‘old’ hand at writing (and everything else…) I wonder if I’ll live long enough to truly explore and clearly reveal the ‘undercurrent’ of some of my ideas and thoughts. I’ve started writing a quite serious book, interlaced with humour. I’ve always been drawn to ‘repercussions’ and how so much affects so many others – guilty or innocent – one way and another, even at the subtlest level. My female protagonist has suffered a ‘confused’ upbringing because of her mother’s behaviour, who – in turn – had a ‘shitty’ life because of her losses and experience, etc.,It makes her a stronger woman (as such a pattern of events and behaviour often seems to, despite a few ‘frail areas’).I enjoy digging deeper,but whether the quality of my writing can best describe or reveal that depth remains to be seen. It’s a fun journey, learning, anyway…(I had an abysmal education but love learning…) Thanks again. Cheers.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for your comment, I appreciate it! I feel the exact same when it comes to writing with themes. But try we must! Your writing sounds very interesting. I like the idea of exploring repercussions. They’re not discussed a great deal in my experience, and the effects are significant. I should add it to the list of examples. Thanks again!

      Like

  2. Hey Richie, good job on tackling a heavy issue! I especially liked the bit about “counters”, a trick I know but tend to forget. 🙂 I feel that themes are something that comes naturally to most writers, in some form or another, although it can be like tying two cats’ tails together when you really set about to implement a theme in your work. I’ve come to the conclusion that themes are something one ought to learn about, then forget – and let the subconsciousness deal with it. It’s a lot more efficient with that kind of thing than our sluggish conscious mind. 🙂

    What about you? Do you have any favourite theme, or something you find yourself coming back to time and again?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you Alice, I appreciate that! I agree, they do seem to come quite naturally. I think it certainly helps to keep them in mind if you’re able to hone in on them before starting a story. Though admittedly I’m struggling with one particular shorty so I’ve decided to push forward and get it done, then come back to it.

      I like the classic good versus evil theme, fear and love, courage, heroism. They’re what intrigues me most. What about you?

      Like

      1. Aw, bummer! Anything I can do to help? The downside with themes is that sometimes you’ve decided on one, and you write an entire story, and then you realise it was not the theme you were looking for… Happens to me on a regular basis!

        I like heroism too! Also, fighting for the underdog is one of my staples. And currently, animal rights. 🙂

        Like

      2. That is a big downside. I’m yet to entangle myself in that particular trap. I love a good underdog story too. In fact, they’re my favourite of all! Got to love animal rights as well. How do you weave that into your stories?

        Like

  3. Great summary of a hard topic. I think the idea of theme can be hard to pin down.Even those examples you offer, such as alienation and betrayal, can slide more towards plot at times. Often I don’t think of a story’s theme as I am writing, but discover it during revision. I had one story I wrote about a bounty hunter chasing a wizard during a blizzard. When I started writing the story, that was all it was. My beta reader pointed out that I was doing interesting things with the snow, reflecting the character’s emotional state. I used that to solidify the theme of animialistic behavior, and the plot/character arc became the character abandoning this sort of life.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s